Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Why default to male? Because multiple generation of us got our writing marked wrong if we used a plural pronoun for a singlaur and "he" was the generic. We used he for unknowns and she for the thing we loved (e.g. ships). I would love for an agreed upon generic, and they is just a bad choice.



It wasn't in my high school English book and I doubt there would be so many people using he if it wasn't taught that way.


Why is they a bad choice? It's worked forever and is already part of the language. Languages evolve.


We trade one dimension of uncertainty for two (count) when we know the count. I just write s/he or avoid pronouns altogether.


We did/do that in German too. Some people still ended up being offended.

Go figure.


And as soon as everyone starts using s/he, bigender people get annoyed that heshe wasn't used. It's language...it's difficult to get everyday usage "normalized" into a different direction.


I nowadays just use he or she (or rather: try to stick to that - I fumble at times when writing casually), in german and in english. The german form is longer, because the noun also has a gender there.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: